What's the Big Idea?
(Adapted from a post that first appeared at inclusionist.org, a blog about social policy.)
The past week was a busy week for progressive economic policy wonks. It started with a cover story in The New York Times Magazine about Sen. Barack Obama’s economic positions; moved to “Poverty Day,” the day on which the U.S. Census Bureau releases income, poverty and insurance data; and ended with the release of EPI’s newest State of Working America report. To boot, numerous speakers at the Democratic Party National Convention have spoken about the problems facing working Americans.
Despite this week’s torrent of data and commentaries – despite this week’s torrent of words – about economic conditions, a coherent story about the problems, causes and solutions is missing. Rather, it seems as if progressive-minded leaders are pulling their punches. In his speech last night, for instance, vice-presidential candidate Joe Biden spoke elegantly about the problems of working families but timidly about solutions. He briefly mentioned such fundamentally conservative solutions as tax cuts and welfare reform before moving on.
But at least Biden exuded passion. The night before, former Virginia Gov. Mark Warner gave a keynote address that was essentially a laundry list of safe, small-bore (a.k.a. “bi-partisan”) economic policies divorced from any larger economic story. What point should working people in struggling communities like those in Virginia’s Appalachian or Southside regions take from Warner’s remarks? That education and rural broadband access are good?
This failure of imagination when it comes to economic policy leads to cautious, incremental steps ill-suited to today’s challenges. (A dynamic that Robert Kuttner describes in an article about balanced budgets in The American Prospect.) Until progressive economic critiques are coupled with a willingness to offer solutions flowing from the critiques, the prospects for meaningful reforms are limited, regardless of what the data say or which party controls the levels of government.



